Press Release | IGB | 02-05-2024

When the lake gets sick

Whether it is circulatory problems, poor nutrition or shortness of breath: human beings and lakes are not so different when it comes to illness.

The analogy of sickness can be transferred from humans to the lake | Photo: Gesa Weyhenmeyer

Like humans, lakes can suffer from a wide range of health problems: from high temperatures to circulatory, respiratory, nutritional or metabolic problems to infections and poisoning. Researchers led by the Swedish University of Uppsala and with the participation of IGB, have highlighted this in a recent study. In order to protect lakes from chronic diseases and threatening conditions and to heal them, strategies similar to those used in human healthcare should be applied: Prophylaxis, regular screening, treatment and mitigation on a local to global scale.

There are 1.4 million lakes worldwide with a surface area of more than 10 hectares. Around 12 per cent of the world's population live within 3 kilometres of these lakes and use them for drinking water, fishing, recreation and tourism. However, lakes can only fulfil these important ecosystem functions if they are in a good health state. 

In a recent study, researchers suggest using human health terminology and approaches to assess and treat the world`s lake system issues. For example, lakes with multiple health problems could be labelled as ‘multimorbid’, and regular screenings similar to human checkups, could help to detect issues in lakes early on. ‘The analogies illustrate that lakes are living systems that need oxygen, clean water and a balanced supply of energy and nutrients,’ said Dr Gesa Weyhenmeyer, a scientist at Uppsala University and first author of the study.

The team used LakeATLAS data from the global compendium HydroATLAS from around 1.4 million lakes worldwide to examine lake maladies of the circulatory (such as floodinig and drying out), metabolic (such as acidification and salinisation), nutritional (such as nutrient excess) and respiratory (such as oxygen deficiency) disorders, along with other types of disturbances. 

Assessing the state of health using reference conditions

But when is a lake healthy – or sick? Many countries have made substantial progress in assessing the health status of their freshwaters in recent decades.  There are approaches, such as the European Water Framework Directive, to harmonise these assessments across countries. 

A key concept of lake health assessments is the comparison of the present status with reference conditions, often defined as conditions that prevail in the absence or near absence of human disturbance. ‘The approach to assessing deviations from reference conditions is similar to practice in the health sector. However, so far there is no simple global system to classify the health status of lakes,’ said Dr Sabine Hilt, scientist at IGB and co-author of the study.

Typical diseases affecting lakes around the world today

1 Severe circulatory problems: 115000 lakes lose twice as much water by evaporation as they receive
Circulation in lakes refers to the availability and dynamics of water. One serious circulation problem with numerous cascading effects on the health of lakes is desiccation. Researchers estimate that around 115000 lakes worldwide evaporate twice as much water as they receive from direct precipitation. This makes them particularly susceptible to drying out if the tributaries also dry out. This jeopardises more than 153 million people who live near these lakes. 

2 Wrong diet: Invasive quagga mussel changes nutrient supply, farmland as a risk for eutrophication
Disturbances in the nutrient balance of a lake also generally lead to an impairment of its ecosystem services. For example, a lack of nutrients can rapidly reduce the productive capacity of a lake. In a lake with a naturally eutrophic nutrient content, fish can no longer find enough food because fewer algae grow. One example of this is the invasive quagga mussel, which in mass populations can filter the lake water to such an extent that the nutrient content drops significantly. However, the opposite is much more often the case: if there are too many nutrients in a lake, this is known as eutrophication. Eutrophication is often associated with (toxic) algal blooms, which can jeopardise drinking water production, for example. Similar to human medicine, there are also risk factors for lakes. The key driver for the global expansion and intensification of algal blooms and toxin production is the cultural eutrophication from domestic, industrial and agricultural waste which is likely exacerbated by climate change.

3 Respiratory issues: Oxygen depletion in lakes more dramatic than in the oceans
Clear signs of lake respiratory issues are dissolved oxygen concentrations far below reference conditions. This is primarily related to algal blooms, warmer water temperatures and low water circulation.  The reason for high temperatures is that less oxygen can be dissolved in warmer water. Small creatures and fish suffocate. Globally, oxygen depletion in lakes is spreading quickly, even faster than in the oceans with no sign of recovery. Hypoxia even affects lakes with good water quality, like observed in Lake Geneva due to milder winters that result in incomplete lake overturn, causing long-term isolation of the deepest part of these lakes from the atmosphere.

Simple assessment system of lake health conditions

"For example, we propose a multi-level classification system from critical to excellent based on defined vital functions," said Gesa Weyhenmeyer. "Excellent" would mean that all vital functions such as oxygen saturation, nutrient concentration, temperature, pH and water clarity are within the normal range. According to the European Water Framework Directive, these results correspond to a good ecological and chemical status of the lake.

Improve diagnostics and implement treatments before problems become chronic

"If lake health problems are left untreated, important ecosystem services will no longer be available or only partially available, jeopardizing the well-being of millions of people. We therefore recommend coordinated, cross-sectoral and multidisciplinary prevention and treatment strategies, which must include monitoring the progress and health status of lakes," said IGB researcher Professor Hans-Peter Grossart, co-author of the study.

Some symptoms of lake health, such as algal blooms, fish kills or floating pollution, are readily visible via processes like satellite observation. However, other problems can only be detected by diagnostic tests, which – like diagnostic tests for humans – can be expensive. 

The team recommends additional research, including testing water samples or installing inexpensive sensors, to get a more comprehensive picture of lake health. The researchers also point out that many lake health issues are widely recognized, but not yet treated. "Better treatment of sewage water, mitigating the effects of climate change and tackling damage caused by humans and non-native species near lakes should be prioritized" summarised Gesa Weyhenmeyer.

Leibniz Institute of Freshwater Ecology and Inland Fisheries
Community and Ecosystem Ecology
PD Dr. Sabine Hilt
Phone +49 30 64181-677
Email: hiltigb-berlin.de

Prof. Dr. Hans-Peter Grossart
Phone +49 33082 699 91
Email: hgrossartigb-berlin.de